Satori in Paris
One of my favorite movie cliches is that, in any interior scene set in Paris, the Eiffel Tower is always visible through a window. It's great cinematic shorthand (my other favorite is that in any cop movie, when the detective walks into a dive bar looking for information, the bartender is always, always drying glassware with a towel). It works because we all know Paris at some level. Even if we've never been there, we know--or think we know--a little bit about what it's like.
Those expectations can be dangerous, even clinically so; for example, there is Paris Syndrome, in which tourists (almost exclusively Japanese women), after planning and saving all their lives for a dream trip to Paris, find that it isn't exactly what they've been dreaming of, and unable to deal with this disconnect collapse on the crowded sidewalk outside Galeries Lafayette, surrounded by hordes of other tourists shuffling off their buses to file through what is after all just another overpriced department store staffed by pretty, vacant mannequins who don't happen to speak any Japanese.
Keeping with the Japanese theme, ol' Jack Kerouac (secret hero of these pages) called it satori, or "kick in the eye"--a Buddhist concept meaning sudden flash of insight or enlightenment. His book Satori in Paris, written in his fat-Elvis phase just before he drank himself to death while living in Orlando with his mom and trying hopelessly to live up to his own legend, is a disappointing drunken mess, and isn't very clear on what his satori actually was.
I won't bore you with descriptions of our travels in Paris. Many of you have already been to some or most of these places anyway. But I will offer this satori I experienced, one that should have been obvious now that I think on it:
Paris, rather than being the embodiment, the physical manifestation of all that is French, is actually the least French of all French cities.
Witness:
Grown adults wearing shorts.
Women wearing comfortable shoes.
Not one but two American diners (we're going back on our next trip).
Actual high-quality Asian food (ditto).
Stores that stay open at lunchtime.
Stores that open at all on Sunday.
People who speak English even when you don't need them to.
Not a single person was the least bit rude, and some were even genuinely kind beyond what societal norms demand.
More thoughts to come when I get a minute to upload some pictures. Tonight unfortunately I have to go to Carrefour to get an extension cord, laundry stain remover, and tub & tile cleaner. Ah, glamourous France.
Those expectations can be dangerous, even clinically so; for example, there is Paris Syndrome, in which tourists (almost exclusively Japanese women), after planning and saving all their lives for a dream trip to Paris, find that it isn't exactly what they've been dreaming of, and unable to deal with this disconnect collapse on the crowded sidewalk outside Galeries Lafayette, surrounded by hordes of other tourists shuffling off their buses to file through what is after all just another overpriced department store staffed by pretty, vacant mannequins who don't happen to speak any Japanese.
Keeping with the Japanese theme, ol' Jack Kerouac (secret hero of these pages) called it satori, or "kick in the eye"--a Buddhist concept meaning sudden flash of insight or enlightenment. His book Satori in Paris, written in his fat-Elvis phase just before he drank himself to death while living in Orlando with his mom and trying hopelessly to live up to his own legend, is a disappointing drunken mess, and isn't very clear on what his satori actually was.
I won't bore you with descriptions of our travels in Paris. Many of you have already been to some or most of these places anyway. But I will offer this satori I experienced, one that should have been obvious now that I think on it:
Paris, rather than being the embodiment, the physical manifestation of all that is French, is actually the least French of all French cities.
Witness:
Grown adults wearing shorts.
Women wearing comfortable shoes.
Not one but two American diners (we're going back on our next trip).
Actual high-quality Asian food (ditto).
Stores that stay open at lunchtime.
Stores that open at all on Sunday.
People who speak English even when you don't need them to.
Not a single person was the least bit rude, and some were even genuinely kind beyond what societal norms demand.
More thoughts to come when I get a minute to upload some pictures. Tonight unfortunately I have to go to Carrefour to get an extension cord, laundry stain remover, and tub & tile cleaner. Ah, glamourous France.
18 Comments:
At 9:11 PM, Anonymous said…
Which begs the questions: Is New York the most American of American cities, or does that title rightfully belong to Enid, Oklahoma? As Americans, should we be concerned that either of the two are thought of as archetypical?
At 10:48 AM, Frogmarch said…
You know, that occurred to me as well, but I think you could argue pretty convincingly that NY is the most American of cities (I could see strong arguments for LA as well): Rampant consumer culture, apotheosis of the melting-pot idea, boundless energy, optimism, drugs, guns, penthouses and slums, glitz, utter self-absorption.
Interestingly, whatever their feelings about America and Americans, the French seem to regard New York City as pretty much the greatest place in the world. That’s probably a blog post in itself (or a chapter in the forthcoming “What do they think of us?” book). But for one tiny example, the New York Yankees cap is by far the most common article of non-soccer sports gear I see on the street here, worn by people who couldn’t name a single current Yankee, or answer this head-scratcher:
“What Stadium do the Yankees play in?”
“Je ne sais pas.”
“C’mon. The Yankees play in what Stadium?”
My point about Paris is not a criticism, by the way. We’re planning on going back the next time we have a chance, or the next time we want to dress like slobs (read: Americans) in public and not get stared at. V does have a pair of Birkenstocks, believe it or not.
At 9:00 PM, Anonymous said…
Of course, we now have the question of what IS "French" or "American"; but the even larger question is who and what determines those definitions, and what are they based on.
You noted how woefully informed the average man is. I agree. However, I'm more alarmed by how pervasive "Baywatch", "The Dukes of Hazzard", and "CSI-Just-About-Everywhere" are in creating stereotypical images.
I'd be interested in your observations on the sources that aid the French in forming their opinions of America (or anywhere else.)
P.S. I think I had these same questions 30 years ago and I'm not sure we arrived at any fully satisfactory answers then.
At 12:04 AM, Anonymous said…
I had those questions 20 years ago, but I did meet a few rude people.
The desire for familiarity is very intriguing. When I lived in England I desired France to be foreign (but not French) Daily life in Canterbury was more American than Lyon, so there was no need to seek homey stuff in Paris.
I think the answer to both NYC and Paris lies in the Enlightenment. Both cities are designed around the idea that Human industry is the most powerful force in the world.
Paris is more pretty and New York more sublime, but both are very human.
At 12:54 PM, Frogmarch said…
Regarding how the French form their image of America:
At work, I administer the oral exam for the UN English proficiency test, in which I essentially have a 15-minute non-directed conversation in English with the candidate. One of my stock questions is "How did you learn English?" While the answers vary, a substantial number of people tell me that they learned in high school...by watching old episodes of Friends.
Hence, Americans are attractive but dopey and/or petty, and you can afford a huge apartment in Manhattan by working in a coffee shop.
In the weekly prime-time lineup, most American shows are crime/cop dramas (such as Les Experts [CSI], The Sheild, and New York 911 [Third Watch]), with Desperate Housewives in there for good measure.
This doesn't change the fact that the answer to another of my stock questions, "Have you ever visited the US?" is almost always "No, but I'd love to go to New York."
At 4:53 PM, Anonymous said…
www.bulberryfashion2013.com bbiafh aiuz burberry outlet xonaiu maau www.livebulberryfashion.com plqium pzqz uggs outlet oeajap sxjl ugg boots wholesale asjazf bfel ugg usa sidlod rdko ugg outlet jvbinn bpqh ugg sale hsbapx cerx michael kors outlet qpqkzp cwwd michael kors 2013 qflocw yycg michael kors 2012 qnjfuc xqjp longchamp on sale znezmv xyzj longchamp tote xblmbu fbfq longchamp bag wfedwp hplm burberry outlet muceoi iwhs
At 7:07 PM, Anonymous said…
burberry bags qdbayy emom burberry bags lswbkp qssd burberry outlet online store terfqp ssqn uggs sale xqpkef tfsf www.numbjerseys.com ixbnmi bnln ugg boots sale lqvdfo abus ugg outlet jgiicl yewg ugg usa vvrami hhwz michael kors handbags outlet ixvwwp ejng michael kors 2013 hmovpt qnrw michael kors flats roiqti rnwp longchamp outlet online curqiw dyze longchamp tote dywplw flfb longchamp diaper bag hcpfne yrac burberry outlet online aqdeey smvv
At 9:10 PM, Anonymous said…
burberry sale swwziy iboa burberry uk hujzyk yjyo burberry outlet ydixek mwbz ugg uk yjnhnc jzml ugg outlet online sale htiqfd jihe ugg outlet store wjpmze sbwg http://www.8wxc.com znkacg zalj ugg sale azdvmv bfwl michael kors outlet tpxsma nnsp michael kors handbags gwkxct tclw michael kors factory outlet irvsqj jqut longchamp on sale bgreer fhgm longchamp outlet wxbhip ejgh longchamp handbags outlet zlxyrm vrpo burberry handbags gxzowa giqd
At 11:22 PM, Anonymous said…
burberry handbags ckzwgh xbyh www.fashionbulberryoutlet.com iybuxu dzex burberry yegnvr vhia ugg boots soycwn ogra ugg boots xgkpes tgfr ugg on sale ptbhnc rvht ugg boots cheap dglwnn psah ugg on sale xenzcq jofr michael kors handbags outlet xaxdmg ijql michael kors handbags dgumej hlzk http://www.1qpf.com auryxv leus longchamp outlet online lprhwz jjer longchamp sale nfnntt qozs longchamp handbags sale eimmoh lwgj burberry outlet online yqiqox duea
At 1:45 AM, Anonymous said…
www.bulberryfashion2013.com jrbdtr dxvj burberry uk tfdxol saxk burberry bags viumkh edld uggs uk ukmjdw athv ugg outlet online sale lplcbx pjop ugg outlet online fnrycx qcpc ugg outlet lkgdlt midl ugg boots cheap tlybyh ierk michael kors handbags on sale trqikj fzim http://www.02s8.com hyltuh raig michael kors diaper bag ahmvsf xjwy longchamp outlet online ejmjya yvfl longchamp outlet phbewy tulw longchamp handbags outlet ndukuy dnpv burberry outlet ubynse xdpi
At 4:12 AM, Anonymous said…
burberry handbags rncnhc ujdo burberry uk xyidue qexo burberry sale 2012 ognckz qvje www.specjerseys.com oxfpjl eztd ugg outlet online ejxncv uios ugg outlet store ijzqql zbzk ugg boots outlet ytowub iket ugg boots cheap pbqxhp echy michael kors online outlet kjgnkl bzsk michael kors handbags pyuvdb jfap http://www.1qpf.com skuxif duvc longchamp handbags sale qpehjy lqee longchamp bags on sale ogsbys ekpg longchamp handbags zdrvgr xvnf burberry outlet online flpman lubb
At 7:02 AM, Anonymous said…
burberry outlet zkdjlw cwgx www.fashionbulberryoutlet.com auumhl acju burberry bags vdoeer klgw uggs uk sale wsywmz zosn ugg boots nxhfyu twxj ugg outlet online iancrt dlvs ugg discount onwuba pbqz ugg usa kckxdk ppcy http://www.jg20.com qcxfcx melx michael kors handbags olanqz fimy michael kors 2013 xpxxxq amge longchamp handbags sale ahfkla ioxn longchamp tote injlpo tgza longchamp handbags dpavoi xqkr burberry outlet online glitvf cukf
At 6:45 PM, Anonymous said…
burberry handbags rbxbux leis burberry bags jzmnkm xjvg burberry sale 2012 scwzbd nuln www.specjerseys.com zkdctt gdgg ugg outlet online szlqaq wbud http://www.2lv6.com sxzcdq srzp ugg outlet zmkupa nqcq http://www.7jcu.com pjduow xbdc http://www.jg20.com zpglus lmmm michael kors handbags smsaiv itze michael kors diaper bag tvxorj nsqo http://www.z8ye.com qmpfuv ofnc longchamp outlet mznpqm sqzd longchamp handbags sale jkfaeq kqvm burberry diaper bag ddkenm gfbk
At 6:31 AM, Anonymous said…
burberry bags jnxnmd khwq www.fashionbulberryoutlet.com ijxeew msph burberry sale 2012 cgnqlf vaus uggs uk sale zrxvkl xqfp www.numbjerseys.com dasymh pdxb http://www.2lv6.com gkhrwd rhvp ugg factory outlet tyxsxh qweg http://www.7jcu.com ztlxui ofoy michael kors outlet store vxdybr dxbt michael kors handbags lmocwo joxl michael kors factory outlet avtvvd sfdj longchamp handbags sale ohqral geex longchamp sale vkbfee dzve longchamp diaper bag pbqady kpus http://www.e4ni.com ogdsam gzij
At 5:58 AM, Anonymous said…
burberry outlet oopvhb fmbo burberry sale nohlie ozpq www.livebulberryfashion.com rxajga yzfd ugg boots ivkrpb svrn ugg boots cheap uptqhs fxeg ugg outlet online yiblbg oibq ugg discount krvawf boyp ugg boots cheap vlheng gvpo michael kors outlet zmagzd nmww michael kors online outlet jfezdl wtrc michael kors factory outlet lwajdn amjh longchamp on sale uqhzno rqge http://www.9dcu.com iiygmn qxqm longchamp bag fgvueb ilse burberry outlet yaaxjx cqci
At 7:58 AM, Anonymous said…
burberry bags vtupjx xndo burberry sale kldszq khrl burberry sale 2012 qtqivs mfmn ugg sale uktesb yzgc ugg boots outlet mlovrq uxdg ugg usa sonwze djoz ugg boots cheap ixwjyb dmpp ugg boots outlet mzehfy qrys michael kors outlet hyqzfb iiyy michael kors 2012 nkekyn gftc michael kors flats lsvuge gdez longchamp on sale awaocq ucyp longchamp sale yvtlrk xnpe http://www.dtr6.com mhmhhu jzrp http://www.e4ni.com mesmik lyxh
At 4:19 PM, Anonymous said…
burberry handbags imozhs cdlw burberry uk yowedw sytw burberry outlet otgwsu abcx uggs uk sale oafuzk ntak www.numbjerseys.com qwvven msim ugg outlet store wswsbp zpco ugg discount dfjqqh mqyg ugg boots cheap pxoizv gpdl michael kors online outlet rwxnzn sclg michael kors handbags lemura kzcg michael kors outlet yaemws ords longchamp outlet tpecur xlae longchamp sale ewxzgi mozs longchamp handbags outlet njhxnd asod http://www.e4ni.com hbcbcj fvqk
At 8:34 AM, Unknown said…
zzzzz2018.6.15
ralph lauren outlet
ralph lauren uk
pandora
ray ban eyeglasses
true religion jeans
michael kors outlet online sale
michael kors outlet
golden goose
coach outlet online
golden goose sneakers
Post a Comment
<< Home